
A punk rock concert promoter was properly convicted of murdering a fan he had kicked out of the venue minutes earlier, the Utah Court of Appeals ruled.
Kevin Neal organized the all-aged punk concert in 2022 in an open space behind a tattoo parlor in Salt Lake City. Fans entered through a narrow alley next to the shop.
Neal denied entry to a fan who the court called “Thomas.” According to Neal’s testimony, Thomas had a “reputation for being either being a rapist or a pedophile.”
Neal said Thomas had a sharp object on his boot that cut Neal’s own boot at a concert five years before the incident. Neal added that he had Thomas kicked out of another show one year before the stabbing.
Thomas attended Neal’s show with a spiked collar around his neck. Neal told Thomas he was not welcome. A shoving match ensued, and onlookers broke it up.
Neal testified that he “was positive (Thomas) would come back” and a second fight “would definitely happen.”
Surveillance footage showed that Thomas returned six minutes later. According to the court, “Thomas appeared to have an object in his hand and making a flipping motion with that hand.”
Neal came out of the alley and the second fight began. After some grappling and striking, Thomas escaped. He left a pool and a trail of blood before collapsing outside a restaurant.
Thomas died after being stabbed nine times: three in the chest, three in the abdomen, two in the neck and one in the scalp.
Neasl admitted to the stabbing but claimed self-defense. He said he felt threatened that Thomas held something metallic that looked like a weapon. Neal said he stabbed Thomas twice in the twice while Thomas was throwing a punch.
A witness heard Neal say, “I just stabbed somebody. I have to get out of here.” Neal also texted his mother, “I might go to jail.”
After the prosecution presented its case, Neal, moved for a directed verdict on self-defense claiming the “fairly long roundhouse punch” justified the stabbing. The court denied the motion.
During closing arguments, “the State pointed to a still image from the footage, contending that it showed that Neal stabbed Thomas before Thomas’s punch had even come close to landing.”
The state also stated that Thomas was unarmed and had that the object was a red vaping device which was recovered from his pocket. Neal was convicted.
The Utah Court of Appeals disagreed with Neal’s assertion that the state failed to prove that he believed that “deadly defensive force was necessary.”
“The evidence strongly suggests that Neal was waiting at the alley entrance with the open knife already in hand, ready to strike, and then stepped toward Thomas as he approached,” Judge Gregory Orme wrote.
“Neal never mentioned self-defense or otherwise claimed that Thomas was armed,” the judge added. “Instead, he declared to bystanders, ‘I just stabbed somebody. I have to get out of here,’ and he told a band member, ‘You need to leave. I just stabbed someone.’”


